Think Tank


Dentistry Redefined | Company Culture | Wellness | Community Service | Podcast | Blog | Social + Dental Consulting | Career + Life Development | Legacy

Removable vs. Fixed Retainers: What’s the Best Option for Your Child?

The path to achieving a perfect smile does not end for your child once their braces are removed.  Even after orthodontic treatment is finished, it is equally as important to preserve your child’s alignment by having them wear a retainer.  These appliances play a critical role in maintaining the results achieved through orthodontic treatment.  At Tebo Orthodontics, we understand that choosing between removable and fixed retainers can be a significant decision for your child’s dental health. This article explores the pros and cons of each option, helping you make an informed choice to ensure your child’s smile remains beautifully aligned.

The Role of Retainers in Post-Braces Care

Retainers are essential for ensuring the longevity of orthodontic treatment after the removal of braces because they prevent teeth from shifting back to their original positions. There are two main types of retainers: removable and fixed.

Understanding Removable Retainers

Removable retainers are custom-made devices that can be taken out and put back into the mouth as needed.  Below are the pros and cons of this type of retainer.

  • Types: The two most common types of removable retainers are Hawley retainers, which are made of acrylic and metal wires, and clear plastic retainers that are similar to aligners.
  • Pros:
    • Ease of Cleaning: Removable retainers can be taken out for brushing and flossing, allowing for better oral hygiene.
    • Convenience: They can be removed before eating and for special occasions.
    • Adjustability: An orthodontist can adjust some types of retainers, like Hawley retainers, to correct minor movements.
  • Cons:
    • Compliance: These are only effective if your child is committed to wearing them as prescribed.
    • Risk of Loss: Removable retainers are at greater risk of being misplaced or lost when taken out of the mouth.
    • Durability: Removable retainers can wear out over time and may need to be replaced.

Exploring Fixed Retainers

Fixed retainers consist of a thin wire bonded to the back of the lower front teeth.  Below are the pros and cons of this type of retainer.

  • Pros:
    • Permanent Protection: Since fixed retainers are bonded to the teeth, they consistently hold teeth in place without relying on your child’s compliance with wearing them.
    • Invisibility: Because the wire is placed behind the teeth, it is not visible when your child smiles.
    • Convenience: Your child will not have to remember to wear this type of retainer, which makes for an easier routine.
  • Cons:
    • Cleaning Challenges: Fixed retainers can make brushing and flossing more challenging, often times requiring special tools and techniques to ensure thorough cleaning.
    • Maintenance: The orthodontist may need to make adjustments at periodic check-ups.
    • Potential for Breakage: Although it is rare for the bonding material to fail, these types of retainers will require repair if this happens.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Retainer

When deciding between removable and fixed retainers, consider the following factors:

  • Oral Hygiene Habits: If your child has excellent oral hygiene, a fixed retainer might be manageable. Otherwise, a removable retainer may be preferable since it can be taken out for cleaning.
  • Compliance and Responsibility: Consider the likelihood that your child is willing to consistently wear and care for a removable retainer.
  • Lifestyle and Activities: Removable retainers offer flexibility for sports, playing musical instruments, and other activities where a fixed retainer might otherwise be inconvenient.
  • Orthodontist’s Recommendation: Your orthodontist can provide guidance and help you make the best decision based on the specific needs and condition of your child’s teeth and bite.

The Importance of Regular Follow-Ups

Regardless of the type of retainer you choose, regular follow-up visits with your orthodontist are essential:

  • Monitoring: Periodic visits allow the orthodontist to continue monitoring the stability of the teeth and make any necessary adjustments.
  • Maintenance: The orthodontist can check to make sure that fixed retainers remain securely in place and that removable retainers fit properly and are in good condition.
  • Reinforcement: They can also provide guidance and additional reinforcement of the importance of wearing removable retainers as prescribed to maintain the results.

Choosing the right retainer is important to preserve the beautiful results of your child’s orthodontic treatment. At Tebo Orthodontics, we are dedicated to providing personalized care and guidance to help you and your child make the best decision, whether opting for removable or fixed retainers.

Need Help Deciding? Contact Tebo Orthodontics today to schedule a consultation. Our team is here to answer your questions and guide you through the process of choosing the best retainer for your child’s needs.

About The Author